Paul's Pizza
About This Spot
Stepping into Paul’s Pizza on North 4th Street is like stepping into a warm corner of a close-knit neighborhood where the pace slows just enough to savor moments — and slice after slice of well-loved pizza. The hum of quiet conversations and the faint crackle of the oven create a familiar backdrop, inviting both longtime locals and curious visitors to settle in with ease.
There’s a simple honesty in the way this spot feels: unpretentious, steady, and welcoming. The team behind the counter moves with practiced care, knowing just how to nurture each pie into a satisfying offering without fuss. It’s the kind of place where the small details—like crisping the bottom just right or generously setting extra cheese on the side—reflect a quiet pride in making food that feels genuine rather than flashy.
Beyond the unmistakable draw of the pizza itself, which often keeps patrons coming back for more, the experience here is about a shared comfort. Whether you’re passing through or making a local ritual out of Thursday night dinner, Paul’s connects people over something as universally simple and joyful as a well-made meal.
Regulars find more than just good food at Paul’s—they find a space that feels familiar and thoughtfully attentive, a counter where stories unfold across thick slices of crust and layers of melted cheese. It’s a neighborhood spot where moments are savored, one heartfelt bite at a time.
What’s Available Here
-
Delivery
-
Takeaway
-
Dine-in
-
Lunch
-
Dinner
-
Solo dining
-
Wheelchair-accessible car park
-
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
-
Comfort food
-
Late-night food
-
Quick bite
-
Lunch
-
Dinner
-
Table service
-
Toilet
-
Casual
-
Family friendly
-
Tourists
-
University students
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
-
NFC mobile payments
-
Credit cards
-
Good for kids
-
Free of charge street parking
-
Free parking lot
Location & Hours
| Monday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM | |
| Tuesday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM | |
| Wednesday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM | |
| Thursday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM | |
|---|---|---|
| Friday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM | |
| Saturday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM | |
| Sunday | 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM |
Zane Voltz 11 Dec 2025
Definitely my favorite. Best pizza in the entire area. I eat it quite often.
Brad Calvert 02 Nov 2025
Pizza was delicious. I do sometimes like mine a little crunchy but it was still delicious and I recommend to anyone who hasn’t tried it. I asked for extra cheese on the side and they very much gave me extra cheese on the side lol and if in area I would get it again
Juanita 27 Oct 2025
THE BEST PIZZA EVER , THAT WE HAVE TASTED IN A LONG TIME. WE JUST HAPPEN TO BE DRIVING BY AND SOOO HAPPY WE STOPPED AT YOURS
Mark Phillips 16 Oct 2025
Excellent pizza shop in Toronto. The guy that is always cooking at night takes the pizza off the pan and puts in oven to crisp up the bottom, and this makes the pizza.
istvan balogh 03 Oct 2025
I’ve been searching for a restaurant in the surrounding area, stupid Ville, Ohio, and Toronto, Ohio. I found this restaurant, and let me tell you, their hoagie is the best I’ve ever had in Ohio. I had to drive to Pittsburgh, as I’m from South Park Suburbs of Pittsburgh, and that’s the only area that I can have found good Italian hoagies. Now Paul’s Pizza is my go to place from now on. Friendly and great food. I highly recommend this Pizza joint for your enjoyment! Five Stars.
Josh Fancher 18 Sep 2025
Easily the best pizza in town and top 5 in the valley.